Skip to content 
As a new mom, choosing the right breast pump can feel like navigating a maze. With so many options on the market, it’s easy to get overwhelmed. Two popular contenders often rise to the top of the list: the Medela Pump in Style vs Spectra S2. But which one is truly the best fit for you and your baby? Let’s dive deep into the world of these powerhouse pumps and help you make an informed decision that aligns with your lifestyle and needs.
Quick Overview
For busy moms on the go, we’ve condensed the key features of both pumps into an easy-to-read comparison table. Whether you’re looking for a quick overview or want to zero in on specific features, this table highlights the main differences between the Medela Pump in Style and Spectra S2. Take a moment to read through – it might just help you make a decision if you’re short on time. For those who want more details, our comprehensive breakdown follows below.
| Feature | Medela Pump in Style | Spectra S2 |
| Max Suction | 290 mmHg | Up to 270 mmHg |
| System Type | Closed system (newer models) | Closed system |
| Noise Level | Moderate (59dB) | Very quiet (45dB) |
| Controls | Simple dial | Digital, customizable |
| Portability | High (battery option available) | Moderate (mainly plug-in) |
| Breast Shield | PersonalFit Flex | Soft silicone |
| Night Light | No | Yes |
| Typical Price | $200-$300 | $150-$200 |
| Part Availability | Widely available | Less common in stores |
| Brand Reputation | Well-established | Well established but newer |
The Contenders: A Brief Introduction
Before we get into the nitty-gritty details, let’s get acquainted with our star players.
The Medela Pump in Style has been a staple in the breastfeeding world for years. Known for its reliability and efficiency, it’s the pump that many moms swear by. On the other hand, the Spectra S2 is a relative newcomer that’s quickly gained a loyal following. It’s praised for its quiet operation and customizable settings.
Both pumps have their strengths, but as we’ll see, they cater to different needs and preferences. Let’s break down the key factors that’ll help you decide which pump deserves a spot in your parenting toolkit.
Pumping Power: The Heart of the Matter
When it comes to breast pumps, suction strength and efficiency are crucial. After all, you want a pump that can get the job done quickly and effectively, especially when you’re juggling a million other tasks.
The Medela Pump in Style offers a maximum suction strength of 290 mmHg and features their patented 2-Phase Expression technology. This tech mimics a baby’s natural nursing rhythm, starting with short, quick sucks to stimulate let-down, then transitioning to longer, deeper pulls for efficient milk extraction.
The Spectra S2, however, ups the ante with a maximum suction strength of 270 mmHg. It also offers customizable letdown and expression modes, allowing you to fine-tune your pumping experience.
While the numbers might suggest the Spectra S2 has an edge, many moms report that both pumps are equally effective at extracting milk. The real difference lies in the customization options and overall pumping experience.
Comfort is Queen: User Experience and Design
Let’s face it: pumping isn’t always the most comfortable experience. But a well-designed pump can make a world of difference, especially if you’re an exclusive pumper or planning to pump long-term.
The Medela Pump in Style comes with PersonalFit Flex breast shields, designed to adapt to your unique shape for a better fit and more comfort. The controls are straightforward, with a single knob for suction adjustment. Newer models also feature a closed system design, which prevents milk from backing up into the tubing and motor, promoting better hygiene.
Spectra S2 takes comfort to the next level with its soft silicone breast shields. Many moms report that these feel gentler on sensitive nipples. The digital controls allow you to adjust both suction strength and cycle speed independently, giving you more control over your pumping session. Like the Medela, it also features a closed system design.
One area where the Spectra S2 really shines is noise level. It’s marketed as a quiet pump, and user reviews back this up. Many moms report being able to pump without waking their sleeping babies or drawing attention in public spaces. The Medela, while not excessively loud, does produce a more noticeable whirring sound.
Portability and Power: Pumping on the Go
For many moms, the ability to pump on the go is a must-have feature. Whether you’re heading back to work or just want the flexibility to pump anywhere, portability matters.
The Medela Pump in Style is designed with mobility in mind. It’s available in both battery-operated and plug-in versions, and its compact design fits easily into a bag or backpack. It even comes with a stylish tote bag for easy transport.
The Spectra S2, while portable, is primarily designed as a plug-in pump. It’s slightly bulkier than the Medela, but still manageable for transport. A rechargeable battery pack is available as a separate purchase, adding to its portability.
Price Point: Bang for Your Buck
Let’s talk money. As a new parent, you’re likely keeping a close eye on your budget, and breast pumps can be a significant investment.
The Medela Pump in Style typically falls in the $200-$300 range, while the Spectra S2 often comes in slightly lower at $150-$200. Both pumps are frequently covered by insurance plans, so be sure to check with your provider.
When it comes to replacement parts, Medela has the advantage of being widely available in stores. Spectra parts might require a bit more hunting, but they’re readily available online.
Real Mom Reviews: The Proof is in the Pumping
While specs and features are important, nothing beats real-world experience. Here’s what some moms have to say about these pumps:
Sarah, a mom of two, says of her Medela Pump in Style: “It’s been my reliable companion through two babies now. It’s not the quietest, but it gets the job done efficiently. I love how easy it is to throw in my bag and go.”
Emily, a first-time mom, raves about her Spectra S2: “The customization options have been a game-changer for me. It’s so quiet, and I love the nightlight feature for those middle-of-the-night pumping sessions. Plus, it’s so gentle on my sensitive skin.”
Medela Pump in Style vs Spectra S2: Which Pump Reigns Supreme?
After diving deep into the features, pros, and cons of both pumps, it’s clear that both the Medela Pump in Style and the Spectra S2 are excellent choices. Your decision will ultimately come down to your personal needs and preferences.
Consider choosing the Medela Pump in Style if:
- You value a brand with a long history and widespread availability of parts
- Portability is a top priority for you
- You prefer simpler controls and don’t need extensive customization
The Spectra S2 might be your best bet if:
- You’re looking for a quieter pumping experience
- Customization of suction strength and cycle speed is important to you
- You want a gentler pumping experience with hospital-grade performance
For more information on breastfeeding and pump options, check out La Leche League International
Remember, the best pump for you is the one that fits seamlessly into your lifestyle and helps you meet your breastfeeding goals. Both these pumps have helped countless moms on their breastfeeding journeys, and either could be the perfect partner for yours.
Whichever pump you choose, remember that you’re doing an amazing job providing for your little one. Happy pumping, mama!
