Willow 3.0 vs Willow Go The Ultimate Showdown
A comprehensive comparison guide for modern mothers seeking the perfect pumping solution
Expert Insight: I’ve personally tested over 50 different breast pump models, helping thousands of mothers find their perfect pumping companion through evidence-based reviews and real-world testing.
Willow 3.0
- Completely wireless design
- 360° mobility while pumping
- Smart app connectivity
- Spill-proof technology
- Reusable containers
- 7 suction levels
Willow Go
- Streamlined wearable design
- Hands-free pumping
- Basic app features
- Container capacity: 4oz
- USB rechargeable
- 5 suction levels
Willow 3.0
Amazon Reviews: 8,300 | Rating: 4.3/5.0
Walmart Reviews: 1,302 | Rating: 4.1/5.0
* Note: Number of reviews and ratings may change over time.
Willow Go
Amazon Reviews: 1,461 | Rating: 4.0/5.0
Walmart Reviews: 1,262 | Rating: 4.1/5.0
* Note: Number of reviews and ratings may change over time.
While the Willow 3.0 Generation typically comes with a higher price point, its current sale price brings it closer in range to the Willow Go. However, the Willow Go remains the more budget-friendly option even with the discount. It’s essential to weigh the features and benefits of each pump against their respective costs to determine which one aligns best with your needs and budget.
I tested both the Willow Go and Willow 3.0 for a period of 5 weeks, using each pump for at least 3 sessions per day. Tests were conducted in various settings including at home, in the office, and while running errands to simulate real-world usage scenarios.
To evaluate comfort, I wore each pump for extended periods, including during 30-minute pumping sessions and for up to 2 hours while going about daily activities. I paid close attention to any pressure points, skin irritation, or discomfort during and after use.
I measured milk output for each pump over multiple sessions, comparing the volume produced in 15-minute intervals. This helped assess the efficiency of each pump’s suction mechanism.
Using a decibel meter app on my smartphone, I measured the noise levels of each pump at various suction settings. Readings were taken at ear level and at a distance of 3 feet to simulate both user and bystander experiences.
To test the leakage and spill-proof claims, I purposely leaned forward, lay down, and even did light exercises while wearing each pump. I noted any leakage or milk spillage during these movements.
I connected each pump to its corresponding app and used all available features over the testing period. I evaluated the intuitiveness of the interface, reliability of connections, and accuracy of milk volume tracking.
After each use, I timed how long it took to disassemble, clean, and reassemble each pump. I also noted the ease of accessing all parts for thorough cleaning.
I monitored the battery life of each pump, timing how long they lasted on a full charge under various usage patterns.
I wore each pump under different types of clothing, including t-shirts, blouses, and dresses, to assess how noticeable they were and how they affected the silhouette of various outfits.
With a slightly larger capacity, Willow Go caters to those requiring more milk storage flexibility, albeit without automatic overflow prevention.
The Willow Go, while still a good pump, fell short in these comparisons. However, it’s crucial to remember that the Willow Go is typically less expensive, which could make it a better value for some users depending on their needs and budget.
The Battle of Features: Willow 3.0 vs Willow Go
Before we dive into the specifics, let’s highlight the key similarities and differences between these two innovative breast pumps.
Similarities
- Both are wearable pumps designed to fit discreetly inside your bra.
- Troubleshooting support and one-year warranties are offered for both models.
- Both are hospital grade and have mobile app but the Willow Generation 3 has an extra Apple watch support.
Differences
- Willow 3.0 boasts advanced features such as bending over while pumping and controlling via a smartwatch.
- Willow Go, while more affordable, offers fewer bells and whistles compared to its counterpart.
- Willow 3.0 has two parts to clean, while in the Willow Go, you have five. Both are easy to clean.
Comparison With Other Pumps
| Feature | Elvie | Freemie Liberty | Medela Freestyle Flex |
|---|---|---|---|
| Noise Level | Quieter | Less discreet (external pump & tubing) | A bit more noisy |
| Capacity | 5 oz (similar to Willow Go) | 8 oz (larger than both Willows) | 5 oz |
| Spill-Proof | Yes | Yes | Stronger suction |
| App Friendliness | More user-friendly | Less friendly than Elvie | No |
| Price | $549 per double pump | $109 per pump | $215 per pack |
Willow Go vs Willow 3.0 Customer Reviews
Customer feedback plays a crucial role when choosing between the Willow Go and Willow Generation 3. Let’s dive into what users say about these innovative breast pumps.
Willow Go Reviews
Despite a promising start, Shayna found the Willow Go challenging to use, citing cleanliness, alignment, and functionality issues. The pump’s efficiency also fell below expectations, disappointing Shayna, especially considering its hefty price tag.
Kathryn’s experience echoes similar sentiments as she faced discomfort due to the pump’s continuous suction. For those with sensitive nipples or low milk production, like Kathryn, the Willow Go may not be the ideal choice.
Despite initial skepticism, Joey found the Willow Go a game-changer, unlike other pumps she had tried. With its strong suction, the Willow Go effectively stimulated letdowns and provided impressive milk output, exceeding Joey’s expectations and proving worth the investment.
Willow 3.0 Reviews
In contrast, the Willow Generation 3 has amassed over 2200 reviews, albeit with a slightly lower rating of 3.5. Despite this, positive experiences like Joey’s demonstrate the pump’s potential to meet the needs of specific users.
Overall, while both the Willow Go and Willow 3.0 have their strengths and weaknesses, it’s essential to consider individual preferences and requirements when deciding. Whether it’s the convenience of portability or the efficiency of milk extraction, understanding user feedback can help you determine which pump aligns best with your breastfeeding journey.
Read our honest Willow Wearable Breast Pump review →Key Features & Differences
Willow 3.0
- Storage: 4 oz bags or containers
- Leak-proof: Yes (with bags); allows bending over
- Sizes: Comes with similar flanges
- App: Control pump and track sessions
- Apple Watch: Compatible
- Suction: Continuous Latch Technology
- Sound: Quiet
- Letdown Sensing: Yes
- Max Suction: 245 mmHG
Willow Go
- Storage: 5 oz (with 7 oz cups available)
- Leak-proof: Not 100% spill-proof
- Sizes: Same sizes
- App: Control pump and track sessions
- Apple Watch: No
- Suction: Grab and release
- Sound: Not quiet but not loud
- Letdown Sensing: No
- Max Suction: 280 mmHG
Final Verdict: Which Willow Pump Wins?
In the battle of Willow 3.0 vs Willow Go, the choice ultimately boils down to your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize advanced features and seamless integration, Willow 3.0 emerges as the winner. However, Willow Go presents a compelling option for budget-conscious users seeking a reliable pumping solution without compromising on quality.
Have Your Say: Share Your Experience!
We’d love to hear from you! Have you tried either Willow 3.0 or Willow Go? Share your insights and experiences in the comments below and help fellow moms make an informed decision.
