I’ve spent countless hours testing breast pumps, over 30 different models, searching for the holy grail of milk expression. While the Medline Breast Pump offers a decent option at an affordable price, it falls short on a few key features that might make you consider other alternatives.
64
Out Of 100
We score breast pumps based on objective testing data. Our scoring factors are weighted based on pump's efficiency, portability, comfortability, hygiene and designed to showcase the best breast pumps.
Overall Score
Performance Tests: Here’s a breakdown of the Medline Breast Pump from a pumping mama’s point of view:
- Efficiency: It averages around 5 oz in 15-20 minutes, less efficient than some top contenders like Spectra and Medela.
- Portability: Similar to Spectra and Medela, it has tubes and a separate unit from the collection bottles. If portability is critical, consider Elvie or Willow pumps.
- Affordability: At around $100, it’s a budget-friendly option. However, for the price point, there are better-performing pumps available.
- Comfort: This is a weak spot. Testers reported the flanges sticking to the skin and milk spills if left unattended.
- Noise: Despite claims of being quiet, my experience found it to be quite loud, making nighttime pumping a challenge.
- Hygiene: Thankfully, the pump is easy to clean despite having multiple parts.
Pros
- Affordable
- Easy to clean
- Possible quiet operation (according to some users)
Cons
- Less efficient than some competitors
- Not very comfortable
- Loud (based on testing)
- Not as portable as some options
Where To Buy:
So, what exactly is the Medline Breast Pump?
It’s a double electric pump offered by Medline Industries, a leading healthcare supplier. It comes with the standard double pump unit, two flanges and collection bottles, tubing, and a tote bag. While the manufacturer doesn’t advertise this, some users have found the pump quieter than others. However, based on my testing, that claim is debatable.
Price and Where to Buy
The Medline Breast Pump costs around $149. You can find it on the Medline At Home website, Amazon, Walmart, and other online retailers. Prices may vary slightly depending on the seller.
Customer Medline Breast Pump Reviews
Customer reviews on Amazon and other platforms paint a mixed picture. Some users appreciate the affordability and ease of cleaning, while others find it uncomfortable and inefficient. The average rating is 3.3/5 based on only 15 reviews, but this number may change with time.
- Bre T, an Amazon customer, thinks this pump is junk. It’s loud and uncomfortable, and the bottle is heavy with the flanges.
- Crystal T thinks that the pump is light and portable, but the buttons are very sensitive and don’t have to be pushed.
- Brittne Eart also added that it’s horrible and not worth it. The suction doesn’t work.
What Sets it Apart?
Not much, honestly; it’s an average pump. At a similar price, better pumps are available for comfort, efficiency, and portability.
The Bottom Line:
The Medline Breast Pump gets the job done but doesn’t excel in any particular area. It might be a decent option if you’re on a tight budget and prioritize ease of cleaning. However, if efficiency, comfort, or portability are essential factors, you’d be better off exploring other pumps.
Here’s a Comparison Table to Help You Decide
| Feature | Medline Breast Pump | Spectra S1 | Medela Pump in Style | Elvie Pump | Willow Pump |
| Price | $100 | ~$200 | ~$200 | ~$500 | ~$500 |
| Portability | Average | Average | Average | Excellent | Excellent |
| Efficiency | Average | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent | Excellent |
| Comfort | Below Average | Excellent | Good | Excellent | Excellent |
| Noise | Average (possibly noisy according to some users) | Quiet | Quiet | Very Quiet | Very Quiet |
| Hygiene | Easy to Clean | Easy to Clean | Easy to Clean | Easy to Clean | Easy to Clean |
Medline Breast Pump Reviews: Not Quite a Crowd Pleaser
While customer reviews aren’t everything, they do offer valuable insights. Here’s a quick look at what users are saying:
- Loves: Affordability, ease of cleaning, quiet operation (for some)
- Hates: Less efficient than others, uncomfortable flanges, spills easily
So, should you buy the Medline Breast Pump?
It depends on your priorities. If affordability is your main concern, it might be worth considering. However, for most moms, there are better pumps out there that offer superior comfort, efficiency, and portability without breaking the bank.
